Transfermarkt Estimates of Player Values in Top-Division Croatian Football
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15291/oec.4180Keywords:
Croatian Football League, Transfermarkt, transfer sales, transfers types, market value, transfer feeAbstract
For many years now, the Transfermarkt website has been the most popular global reference point for market value estimates of football players. Since most top-flight Croatian football clubs lean heavily on financing through the sale of player registrations, it is useful to know by how much valuation estimates of that portal differ from actual transfer fees, as well as how many players are transferred with financial compensation involved. Analyzing Croatian first league clubs over a period of ten playing seasons, this paper found that no transfer fees were recorded in the majority of outgoing transfers (at least in 55% of cases, but probably up to 85%). Consequently, the total transfer value is up to 40% lower than total market value estimates of these players on Transfermarkt at the time of their departure from clubs. However, when considering only transfers with paid compensation, market value estimates from Transfermarkt and transfer fees almost overlap, with a difference of only 1,5%. A strong and significant statistical relationship between market value estimates and transfer fees has been confirmed, but only for outgoing transfers where compensation was actually paid. The probability of a paid transfer increases with increasing market value - especially above one million euros per player - and an increased market value also enhances the accuracy of future transfer fees assessments. Since more successful Croatian clubs have more players with higher market values in their squad, Transfermarkt's estimates are more accurate for them than for less successful domestic clubs.
References
th UEFA Club Licensing Benchmarking Report (2020), dostupno na: https://www.uefa.com/MultimediaFiles/Download/OfficialDocument/uefaorg/Clublicensing/02/64/06/95/2640695_DOWNLOAD.pdf
th UEFA Club Licensing Benchmarking Report (2023), dostupno na: https://editorial.uefa.com/resources/027e-174740f39cc6-d205dd2e86bf-1000/ecfl_bm_report_2022_high_resolution_.pdf
Alajbeg, D., Bubaš, Z., Milovanović B. (2022), Financial Health and Self-Sustainability of a Small European Football League: The Realities of Top-Flight Croatian Football, Sustainability, 14(24), 16599, https://doi.org/10.3390/su142416599
Arnerić, J., Statističke metode za ekonomske analize (bez. dat), Bookdown, dostupno na: https://bookdown.org/jarneric/predavanja_smea/
Coates, D., Parshakov, P. (2022), The wisdom of crowds and transfer market values. European Journal of Operational Research, 301(2), 523-534.
FIFA Global Transfer Report 2022 (2023), dostupno na: https://www.fifa.com/legal/media-releases/fifa-publishes-global-transfer-report-2022-with-all-time-record-setting-numbers
Frick, B. (2007), The football players’ labor market: Empirical evidence from the major European leagues. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 54(3), 422–446, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9485.2007.00423.x
He, M., Cachucho, R, Knobbe, A. (2015), Football Player's Performance and Market Value, Zbornik radova s konferencije: Proceedings of the 2nd workshop of sports analytics, European Conference on Machine Learning and Principles and Practice of Knowledge Discovery in Databases (ECML PKDD), Porto, Portugal
Herm, S., Callsen-Bracker, H.-M., Kreis, H. (2014). When the crowd evaluates soccer players’ market values: Accuracy and evaluation attributes of an online community, Sport Management Review (Elsevier Science), 17(4), 484–492.
Galton, F. (1907), Vox populi, Nature, 75, 450–451.
Gerhards, J., Mutz, M., Wagner, G. (2014), Die Berechnung des Siegers: Marktwert, Ungleichheit, Diversität und Routine als Einflussfaktoren auf die Leistung professioneller Fußballteams / Predictable Winners. Market Value, Inequality, Diversity, and Routine as Predictors of Success in European Soccer Leagues, Zeitschrift für Soziologie, 43(3), https://doi.org/10.1515/zfsoz-2014-0305
GNK Dinamo (2023), Revidirani godišnji konsolidirani financijski izvještaji za posebne namjene za 2022. godinu, dostupno na: https://gnkdinamo.hr/hr/Novosti/Clanak/F.02_Godisnji_financijski_izvjestaji_nakon_revizije_za_2022
HNK Gorica (2023), Godišnji financijski izvještaji nakon revizije za 2022. godinu, dostupno na: https://www.hnk-gorica.hr/UserDocsImages/vijesti/dokumenti/F.02_Financijski%20izvje%C5%A1taji%20sa%20bilje%C5%A1kama%20i%20_Izvje%C5%A1%C4%87e%20neovisnog%20revizora.pdf?vel=15442281
HNK Hajduk (2023), Izvješće o obavljenoj reviziji konsolidiranih financijskih izvještaja HNK Hajduk š.d.d. Split za 2022. godinu sukladno pravilniku Hrvatskog nogometnog saveza o licenciranju klubova, dostupno na: https://hajduk.hr/pdf/financijsko-izvjesce-2022-/480
HNK Rijeka (2023), Revidirani godišnji kombinirani financijski izvještaji za posebne namjene za 2022. godinu koji uključuju HNK Rijeka s.d.d. i Stadion Kantrida d.o.o., dostupno na: https://nk-rijeka.hr/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Licenciranje-HNK-Rijeka-s.d.d.-za-2022.-godinu.pdf
HNS (2023), Prijelazni rokovi i drugi rokovi HNS-a za registraciju igrača i igračica iz inozemstva za 2023. godinu, dostupno na: https://hns-cff.hr/files/documents/24453/Prijelazni-rokovi_2023.pdf
Jeroen Ruijg, J., Ophem, H. (2014), Determinants of football transfers, UvA-Econometrics Working Papers, 14-01
Keppel, P., Claessens, T. (2020), How the volunteers of data website Transfermarkt became influential players at European top football clubs, dostupno na: https://www.ftm.eu/articles/transfermarkt-volunteers-european-football#:~:text=Transfermarkt%20may%20be%20better%20than,Follow%20the%20Money%20points%20out
Müller, O., Simons, A., Weinmann, M. (2017a), Beyond crowd judgments: Data-driven estimation of market value in association football, European Journal of Operational Research, 263(2), 611–624, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2017.05.005
NK Istra 1961 (2023), Financijski izvještaji na dan 31. prosinca 2022. godine s izvješćem revizora - Sukladno Pravilniku o licenciranju i financijskoj uspjebnosti klubova HNS-a -, dostupno na: https://nkistra.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/F.02_Godisnji-financijski-izvjestaji-nakon-revizije-za-2022.pdf
NK Lokomotiva Zagreb (2023), Godišnji financijski izvještaji i Izvještaji neovisnog revizora za 2022. godinu, dostupno na: https://nklokomotiva.hr/dokument/f.02_godisnji-financijski-izvjestaji-nakon-revizije-za-2022.-15
NK Osijek (2023), Revidirani financijski izvještaji na dan 31. prosinca 2021. godine (Kombinirano sa Škola nogometa NK Osijek i FM 20 d.o.o.), dostupno na: https://nk-osijek.hr/files/documents/160/F.02_Godis%CC%8Cnji%20financijski%20izvjes%CC%8Ctaji%20nakon%20revizije%20za%202022.pdf
NK Slaven Belupo (2023), Godišnji financijski izvještaji i Izvješće neovisnog revizora za 2022. godinu, dostupno na: https://nk-slaven-belupo.hr/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/F.02_Godisnji-financijski-izvjestaji-nakon-revizije-za-2022..pdf
Peeters, T. (2018), Testing the Wisdom of Crowds in the field: Transfermarkt valuations and international soccer results, International Journal of Forecasting, 34(1), 17–29.
Poli, R., Besson, R., Ravenel, L., Econometric Approach to Assessing the Transfer Fees and Values of Professional Football Players, Economies, 10(1), 4, https://doi.org/10.3390/economies10010004
Prockl, F., Frick, B. (2018), Information Precision in Online Communities: Player Valuations on www.transfermarkt.de, International Journal of Sport Finance, 13(4), 319–335.
Surowiecki, J. (2004), The wisdom of crowds: Why the many are smarter than the few and how collective wisdom shapes business, economies, societies, and nations (1st ed), Doubleday.
