The problem of Kants solution of the facticity and the universality of values

Authors

  • Dušan Travar University of Zadar

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15291/radovifpsp.2643

Keywords:

moral philosophy, freedom, transcendental, naturalistic fallacy, facticity, mind, philosophy of religion

Abstract

The author proceeds from the assumption that the empiric tenet cannot be carried out unless it has resulted from a universalization based upon not only the customs themselves but upon moral judgment as well. Kant's model of the moral judgment appears somewhat vague insofar as it disregards social implications. Teleological presumptions covering the period from the Old Greece times up to the Middle Ages do not differentiate "what is" from "what ought to be". Such a clash was introduced by Descartes's quantification of fact as well as by his rationalization of value. In what follows moral discovery has been approached relying upon the so-called naturalistic fallacy objection as well as upon Kant's unification of fact and value. The closing passage of the article deals with the deistic aspect of Kant's philosophy of religion which supports moral religion and ethical/civil society. Kant's critique of some aspects of the Church in terms of its institutional structure is also discussed as well as his defense of man as moral being.

References

KANT, I. (1968): Werke in zwölf Bände, Theorie-Werkausgabe, herausgegeben von Wilhelm Weischedel, Frankfurt am Main, Suhrkamp Verlag. Prema tom izdanju ću navoditi naziv djela, svezak i stranicu. Kratica: Weischedel. Prijevodi navoda su moji.
KANT, I. (A 1781, B 1787): Kritik der reinen Vernunft, izd. Weischedel, svezak III i IV. Kratica: KrV.
KANT, I. (1785): Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten, izd. Weischedel, svezak VII. Kratica: GMS.
KANT, I. (1788): Kritik der praktischen Vernunft, izd. Weischedel, svezak VII. Kratica: KpV.
KANT, I. (A1790, B1793): Kritik der Urteilskraft, izd. Weischedel, svezak X. Kratica: KU.
KANT, I.: [nastalo do 1790, tiskano tek kasnije. 0 tome vidi Pogovor izdavača u X. svesku, S. 623-625], izd. Weischedel, svezak IX. Kratica: EE.
KANT, I. (1793): Die Religion innerhalb der Grenzen der blossen Vernunft, izd. Weischedel, svezak VIII. Kratica: Rel.
KANT, I.: Aus Sömmering: über das Organ der Seele, izd. Weischedel, svezak XI. Kratica: AS.

Published

2018-04-24

Issue

Section

Original scientific paper