Heritage conservation in war and post-war conditions during the 1990s
The case of Dubrovnik Research Library
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15291/libellarium.4215Keywords:
crisis management, cultural heritage institutions, Dubrovnik Libraries, preventive conservation, warAbstract
Purpose. The aim of the paper is to describe the activities undertaken by Dubrovnik Libraries during and after the Croatian War of Independence to preserve their heritage collections. The intention is also to present plans for possible future challenges as well as to compare the conditions, resources and equipment available in the 1990s and in the present.
Approach/methodology. The paper shows the degree of damage to the Library collections through an in situ case study, the basic data on how evacuation was approached, the organisation of work in crisis conditions, the storage of collections during the war period and then the relocation to the new building. The paper was based on primary sources, including first-hand accounts by the former Library Director Mrs Urban and interviews with older or retired librarians, and secondary sources such as the official report by a paper conservationist who conducted the inspection of damaged library materials in situ, newspaper articles, books, periodicals, doctoral thesis, emergency plan and measures etc. The research for this paper also enabled cooperation between librarians and conservators, as well as finding,
scanning and archiving valuable historic library documents, which will be, as a result, available to any future researchers and for posterity.
Findings. The paper presents a valuable experience of how endangered cultural heritage was protected in the past and offers contemporary insights into improving the methods of storing, preventive protection and transporting books and archive materials. To avoid previous mistakes, Dubrovnik Libraries developed the crisis response plan with emergency measures in 2020, while in the previous years numerous new resources and equipment had been put into place.
Value. The paper gives an overview of a thirty-year long process of caring for heritage collections and it presents perspectives from both librarians and conservators. It outlines the way new resources – human, financial and technological – were used after the war to repair the damage and prevent anything similar from occurring in the future. Hopefully, this paper will raise awareness among cultural institutions and serve as a valuable aid in the practice of crisis management as well as preventive care.
Downloads
References
Alten, Helen. 1999. “Temperature and Relative Humidity. How Temperature and Relative Humidity Affect Collection Deterioration Rates.” Collections Caretaker 2, no. 2 (Fall). https://www.collectioncare.org/pubs/v2n2p1.html.
Aparac-Gazivoda, Tatjana, and Dragutin Katalenac, eds. 1993. Wounded Libraries in Croatia. Zagreb: Croatian library association.
Baer, Norbert S. and Margaret Holben Ellis. 1988. “Conservation Notes: On Thymol Fumigation.” International Journal of Museum Management and Curatorship 7, no. 2: 185-188.
Bijelić, Gabrijela. 1995. “Nema vremena za čekanje: Knjižni fundus Znanstvene knjižnice izložene propadanju: Spomenički fond u trezorima banke.”Slobodna Dalmacija, January 14, 1995. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/view-Page/?pv_page_id=699647.
Bijelić, Gabrijela. 1998. “Ragusina u Skočibuhi.” Slobodna Dalmacija, August 20, 1998. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/viewPage/?pv_page_id=804013.
Bogdanović, Jelena. n.d. “Povijest Dubrovačkih knjižnica.“ Dubrovačke knjižnice. Accessed July 4, 2023. https://www.dkd.hr/o-knjiznici/povijest.
Brailo, Nensi. “Librocide: Destruction of Libraries in Croatia 1991-1995.” Master’s Theses, San Jose State University, 1998. https://scholarworks.sjsu.edu/etd_theses/1688.
Chapman, Patricia. 1990. Guidelines on Preservation and Conservation Policies in the Archives and Libraries Heritage. Paris: UNESCO.
Dubrovačke knjižnice. n.d. “Palača Bassegli-Kaboga.” Accessed July 26, 2023. https://znanstvena.dkd.hr/o-knjiznici/palaca-bassegli-kaboga.
Dubrovačke biblioteke. 1992a. Zapisnik o izvršenoj evakuaciji trezorske sobe NČB Dbk u vremenu od 9. do 15.07.1992. Dubrovnik, Dubrovačke biblioteke. Unpublished manuscript.
Dubrovačke biblioteke. 1992b. Zapisnik o evakuaciji fonda “STARA RAGUSINA”, dana 9., 10., 11. i 12. srpnja 1992. godine. Unpublished manuscript.
Fire Trace International. n.d. “FM-200™ Fire Suppression Systems.” Accessed 29 October, 2023. https://www.firetrace.com/en/fm-200.
Gustin, Olivija. 1998. “Kada je u srpnju 1992. … .” Unpublished newspaper article.
Hoel, Ivar A. L. 1998. “Standards for Permanent Paper.” 64th IFLA General Conference August 16 – August 21, 1998. http://archive.ifla.org/IV/ifla64/115-114e.htm.
ICOM-CC. 2008. Resolution Adopted by the ICOM-CC Membership at the 15th Triennial Conference, New Delhi, 22-26 September 2008. Terminology to Characterize the Conservation of Tangible Cultural Heritage. New Delhi. https://www.iccrom.org/sites/
default/files/2022-02/icom_cc_resolution_on_terminology_english.pdf.
IFLA. n.d. Document Storage Mode. Preservation and Conservation (PAC) Programme. https://www.ifla.org/document-storage-mode/.
Jerinić, Mato. 1998. “Plijesan pojela blago.” Slobodna Dalmacija, 23. lipnja 1998. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/viewPage/?pv_page_id=798078.
Jerinić, Mato. 1992. “Spašene knjige nakon razaranja dvorca Skočibuha.” Slobodna Dalmacija, 23. lipnja 1992. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/view-Page/?pv_page_id=535182.
Laszlo, Želimir i Dragojević, Andreja. 2010. Priručnik preventivne zaštita umjetnina na papiru. Zagreb: Crescat.
Marunić, Anet. 1993. “Knjižno blago u trezorima.” Slobodna Dalmacija, 22. rujna 1993. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/viewPage/?pv_page_id=647886.
Mesarić-Žabčić, Rebeka. 2009. “Posljedice Domovinskog rata: Primjer Dubrovačko-neretvanske županije.” U Demografski kontekst i sociokulturne posljedice Hrvatskoga domovinskog rata, uredili Dražen Živić, Ivana Žebec, 165-177. Zagreb – Vukovar: Institut Ivo Pilar.
Mikuličin, Ivana. 1998. “Zbirka Ragusina – od knjiga samo prah?”. Slobodna Dalmacija, 29. srpnja 1998. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/view-Page/?pv_page_id=802084.
Mušnjak, Tatjana. 1998. Izvješće o stanju zbirke Ragusina Dubrovačkih knjižnica Dubrovnik. Unpublished manuscript.
National Center for Biotechnology Information. 2023. “PubChem. Compound Summary. Thymol.” National Library of Medicine. Accessed July 12, 2023. https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/Thymol.
Orlić, Marijan. 1992. Zapisnik o evakuaciji fonda “Stara Ragusina” dana 9., 10., 11. i 12. srpnja 1992. Unpublished manuscript.
Peko, Paulina. 1997. “Znanstvena knjižnica u palači.” Slobodna Dalmacija, 17. srpnja 1997. https://arhiv.slobodnadalmacija.hr/pvpages/pvpages/viewPage/?pv_page_id=765105.
Republika Hrvatska Ministarstvo kulture i medija. n.d. Pretraživanje Registra kulturnih dobara: Ljetnjikovac Stjepanović-Skočibuha, Lista zaštićenih kulturnih dobara, Z-5512. Accessed January 5, 2024.https://registar.kulturnadobra.hr/#/details/Z-5512.
Regionalni zavod za zaštita spomenika kulture Split. 1989. Rješenje br. 17/9-89 (18. srpnja 1989). Split, 1989, typescript.
Seferović, Sonja. 1992. “Dan D za knjižnice.” Dubrovački vjesnik, 20. lipnja 1992.
Seferović, Sonja. 1998. “Raguzina ponovno na svjetlu dana.” Dubrovački vjesnik, 29. kolovoza 1998.
Suton, Ante. 2020. Plan mjera za slučaj opasnosti. Zagreb: Tehnoekspert d.o.o.
Šapro-Ficović, Marica. “Djelovanje knjižnica pod opsadom u ratu: studija slučaja: Hrvatska 1991/1995. godine.” Doktorska disertacija, Sveučilište u Zagrebu, 2012.
UNESCO World Heritage Collection. n.d. “Old City of Dubrovnik.” Accessed July 10, 2023. http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/95/.
Urban, Mirjana. 1992. “Znanstvena knjižnica Dubrovnik: dan poslije.” Vjesnik bibliotekara Hrvatske 35, no. 3-4: 94-97.
Urban, Mirjana. 2021. Prva javna knjižnica u Dubrovniku s posebnim osvrtom na razdoblje od 1985. do 2000. Unpublished manuscript.
Vokić, Denis. 2007. Preventivno konzerviranje slika, polikromiranog drva i mješovitih zbirki. Zagreb: K-R Centar: Hrvatsko restauratorsko društvo: Udruga Gradine i godine.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Paula Raguz, Tina Di Reda, Damjan Polić

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


